Clooney Challenges O'Reilly
January 10, 2005 George
Clooney is going on the offensive against FOX News star
Bill O'Reilly. "Extra" has obtained a copy
of the open letter Clooney fired off to O'Reilly Monday
morning, chastising the pundit for questioning the validity
of the fundraising efforts Clooney led for both 9/11
and the tsunami victims.
Clooney's letter begins tersely, stating: "First,
to clarify it was not the Red Cross but the United Way
that sponsored that telethon, an easy mistake to make
if you're 3."
Clooney also takes on O'Reilly for using the fundraising
topic to boost his own ratings. "Your report last
Thursday was a preemptive strike, not to protect the
families affected by the tsunami but to create more
controversy for your own personal gain."
Clooney does offer a solution, closing with an invitation
to join the Saturday telethon. "This is your chance
to put your considerable money where your considerable
mouth is," Clooney wrote. "Show up, help raise
money and if we're doing something wrong point it out."
Below are the complete texts of Clooney's letter and
O'Reilly's original statement:
January 10, 2005
Mr. O'Reilly,
In response to your lead story on January 6, where you
attack the Sept. 11 telethon, it is incumbent upon me
to help you get your facts straight.
First, to clarify, it was not the Red Cross but the
United Way that sponsored that telethon... an easy mistake
to make... if you're 3.
Second, contrary to what you claim, no one objected
to you investigating where the funds were going, but
we strenuously objected to you insinuating that it was
a fraud (which is what you did) as we were still waiting
for a list of names of the dead. 6,000 was the number
when you broadcast your attack (some 3,000 was the real
number), that is simply a fact... no spin. There's no
question, sir, that you have become quite powerful.
The panic that you started that week scared other charitable
organizations into simply handing out money to anyone
who walked into their office. I suppose the threat of
a Senate investigation would scare most anybody. It
was an interesting week though... you showed up on the
Today Show to talk about the telethon, but when pressed
by Matt Lauer, admitted that you would only talk about
the scandal if they hawked your new book. Fact... no
spin. You said your tactics weren't about ratings, and
that same week took out ads bragging about beating Larry
King for the first time, all while Eliot Spitzer and
Frank Thomas and Josh Gotbaum were weeding through the
difficult task of who was dead and who was not.
I don't make as much money as you, Mr. O'Reilly (a fact
that's easy to check), but I'm fascinated by your use
of the word CELEBRITY as if you're not one... you put
on make up, you do Leno, The Today Show, go on book
tours, and do junkets, so let's be clear... you are
a well paid celebrity. Period. No spin. And, to quote
you last week, "with power comes responsibility"...
people canceled their pledges because YOU told them
that the telethon was flawed... a lot of money that
should have gone to a lot of needy families didn't,
because you wanted a controversy... and controversy
has made you a celebrity... remember, sir, that this
is me you're talking to publicly. I was the one you
called several times the day before the telethon to
say that we "had to include 'The Factor'"
in the press interviews, and that it "wasn't fair
to leave us out, we're a news program". Fact...
no spin. I think people should know that.
Now, here's the only important fact: the 9/11 telethon
was an unqualified success from the beginning to the
present and we make sure of it. (I say WE because I'm
on the board of directors of the United Way).
Your report last Thursday was a preemptive strike...
NOT to protect the families affected by the tsunami,
but to create more controversy for your own personal
gain. Because of it, fewer people will donate money
to help truly traumatized victims; they'll be afraid
that their money will do no good.
So all right, Mr. Journalist... come on in. I'm booking
the talent for the Tsunami event... and you, Mr. O'Reilly,
are now officially invited to be a presenter... (at
this point, not one of the people I've invited to donate
their time has said "No")... this way, You
can personally follow up on our fundraising... this
is your chance to put your considerable money where
your considerable mouth is... show up... help raise
money... and if we're doing something wrong, point it
out. I believe firmly in the check and balance system...
you'll get nothing but a handshake and a "Thanks
for helping out" from all of the rest of us "celebrities".
So what do you say, Mr. O'Reilly... either you ante
up and help out AND be that watch dog that you feel
we clearly need... or you simply stand on the sidelines
and cast stones, proving that your January 6 TV show
was nothing more than a "box of lights and wires"
designed to make you wealthy.
We do the show this Saturday, it's across the street
from where you shoot "The Factor".
I'll need a quick response.
Your fan,
George Clooney
Stars, Money and the Tsunami...
Thursday, January 06, 2005
By Bill O'Reilly
Stars, money, and the tsunami: they are the subjects of
this evening's "Talking Points Memo."
As Yogi Berra once said, "it is deja vu all over
again." You may remember that in the aftermath of
the 9/11 attack, there was a celebrity-driven TV telethon
that raised millions for the affected families. And now,
there will be another telethon raising money for those
hurt by those the tsunami.
And once again, our pal [actor] George Clooney will be
involved. You may also remember that Clooney strenuously
objected to "The Factor" investigation that
uncovered problems in distributing the 9/11 money, even
though we proved our case and the Red Cross revamped its
entire operation because of it.
Clooney objected to many things, but one of them was my
insistence that if celebrities ask for money, they have
a moral obligation to see the donations go where they're
supposed to go. -- Clooney disagreed.
So now we're back in the same spot. A national TV telethon
will raise millions and "The Factor" will be
watching to see if the money gets to the tsunami victims.
If it does not, there will be trouble. And this time nobody
can say they weren't warned.
If George Clooney and other stars go on TV and ask you
to give, then they had better be involved all the way
down the line. Now I don't expect the celebrities to audit
the books, but if problems are brought to their attention,
they must help solve those problems.
Sending billions of dollars into chaotic areas is fraught
with danger, even if is the right thing to do. Americans
must demand reasonable accountability. We expect some
of the money to be stolen or wasted. But we also expect
American authorities to hold people accountable and to
let us know if bad things are happening. "Talking
Points" believes the American people are the most
generous in the world. But it is our job here to make
sure you are not taken advantage of. And we will do that
job. We want the telethon to be a big success and we applaud
the time and generosity of George Clooney and the other
stars. But with power comes responsibility. And we expect
all the telethon people to understand that.
|