ABC's reality Romeo, Jesse Palmer, made the most important decision of his life Wednesday night, choosing 21-year-old Jessica and sending a devastated Tara home empty handed.

But surprisingly, after Jesse told Tara he had fallen in love with someone else, she responded, "Things that were said and done on our last alone date I honestly think were completely inappropriate." The quote left millions of viewers wondering exactly what went on behind the closed doors.

Only "Extra" was with Tara just a few hours after the brush-off, and she admitted "I did fall in love, and I did get my heart broken."

Tara told us she knew bad news was coming: "As soon as I saw Jesse, something wasn't right."

And Jesse gave Jessica a surprise of her own when, instead of presenting her with the engagement ring that the two shopped for together, he gave her a one-way plane ticket to New York, asking her to, "Chase all your dreams, but do it with me."

"Extra's" followed Jesse's adventures from the beginning, and we were right there with the happy couple the day after their big night to find out if this NFL quarterback was serious.

"When I look at her I think about marriages, I think about children and family reunions," Palmer told us. "I think about big Christmases, and those are things I've always really dreamt about."

So will Jessica move to New York? And what made Tara so upset? Find out more in the "After the Final Rose" special next week on ABC.